Home Economics The Argument Against Industrial Policy - It Will Be Designed By The...

The Argument Against Industrial Policy – It Will Be Designed By The Ignorant

Author

Comments

An industrial policy is something every politician thinks we should have because it means that politicians get to design the industrial policy – act as Fat Controllers for the economy. The argument against an industrial policy is that politicians will design it. The thing being that things designed by the ignorant tend not to enhance life.

Conservative Home has been running a short series about what that industrial policy should be. Here’s the contribution from Alan Mak (who the hell he? – Ed):

The on-going trade dispute between the US and China has put the spotlight on so-called “critical minerals”. We in Britain cannot afford to be passive observers. Instead, we should take an active interest in this key strategic and economic issue, and play a leading role in safeguarding access to critical minerals, both for ourselves and our Five Eyes allies. Ensuring our scientists, manufacturers and technology businesses have a secure and reliable supply of critical minerals is vital for Britain’s leadership of the Fourth Industrial Revolution.

Critical minerals consist of the 17 Rare Earth Elements (REE) recognised by the International Union of Pure and Applied Chemistry, with names such as promethium and scandium, plus other economically valuable

This is going to start sounding picky but this is concerning my professional expertise (ie, not journalistic nor think tank but actually having been there and done that). Using promethium as an example of rare earths (to emphasise the professional competence there was a about a decade back there when I handled 50% of the world’s consumption of scandium each year) is just silly. While it is indeed one we don’t in fact get it from rare earth deposits. Because it’s radioactive, d’ye see? And with a fairly short half life, meaning that if we stored some and then came back to use it then we’d have a nice lump of mixed Nd and Sm, not the original Pm.

In fact the half life is so short that globally there’s perhaps a pound of it – 1lb – at any one time in the naturally occurring stock. Which is why we don’t go get it from the rare earth ores it’s not in but pick it out of the wastes of a nuclear reactor instead.

I know, I know, minor point except someone who starts off like this is clearly not entirely au fait with the world he’s trying to plan nor regulate, is he?

but relatively rare minerals such as lithium and cobalt (used in batteries), tungsten (used in defence products including missiles), bauxite (the source of aluminium) and graphite (key to battery production).

Lithium, cobalt, tungsten, these are not minerals they are elements. Yes, this is important – see above about not being au fait. When talking about bauxite – which, to be fair, actually is a mineral – the leap is to the other end of absurdity. Bauxite is one of the most common minerals upon the planet. That it’s $50 a tonne – a price we’ll use among us friends – isn’t an indication of great rarity now, is it?

Although they are more abundant than their name implies, REEs and critical minerals are difficult and costly to mine and process. Converting critical minerals embedded in rocks from under the Earth’s crust to separated elements is a complex and costly process which often involves the use of highly concentrated acids and radiation.

No, it doesn’t involve radiation. That would mean our pouring particles into the ores in order to create or separate out the individual metals. Which isn’t what we do at all, that’s an entirely different process called transmutation. Entirely possible of course and something regularly done in research and isotope production reactors. But not how we gain our REEs – other than promethium.

What he means is that there are wastes from the process that are radioactive. Which indeed there are, there’s almost always some thorium around which has to be stored off somewhere. But that’s not “radiation”. No, there’s no mileage in saying well, it’s sorta the same thing. This bloke wants to pan this sector of the economy for us and he keeps using words and concepts which just don;t apply. That’s not going to result in a good plan, is it?

For example, the Democratic Republic of the Congo was responsible for around 90 per cent of the world’s cobalt production in 2018, whilst Guinea dominates bauxite, with around 35 per cent of the world’s reserves.

Cobalt? DRC? No, more like 65%. Bauxite reserves? Again, this is betraying a woeful ignorance of the subject under discussion. Reserves just means who has gone out and measured the stuff. The availability of things we can make aluminium from is essentially inexhaustible given that Al is one of the commonest elements in the lithosphere.

The solution is, apparently:

The Five Eyes intelligence sharing partnership between Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the USA and the UK has been in existence since 1941 and provides the perfect foundation on which we should develop a new critical minerals reserve that would end our collective vulnerability of supply.

The reserve would consist of inter-connected physical national stockpiles of critical minerals, and then extend to become a processing chain that all partners could draw on.

Why would it benefit us to have a stockpile of promethium? Or, say, tungsten? We can always go dig up a bit more of Cornwall to get that. A stockpile of bauxite is ludicrous – we don’t have an alumina refinery to process it, we don’t even have an aluminium smelter to process the alumina. We do though already have a lot of aluminium furnaces which can reprocess aluminium scrap meaning we don’t need the bauxite anyway.

We need more facilities like the University of Birmingham’s Recycling Plant at Tyseley Energy Park, which is pioneering new techniques that are transforming the recycling of critical minerals such as neodymium, which is commonly found in hard disk drives.

No, it isn’t. It’s commonly found in the magnets in HDDs. This being important because it’s found there in gramme quantities. Worth, once processed, perhaps 3 pence per HDD. Which isn’t really worth reprocessing an HDD for. It’s also not found in the more modern ones.

It is though found in the magnets for windmills – but there in tonne quantities which are more interesting.

The point about all of this being to show why industrial policy is always such a dud. It’s designed by politicians – by definition the people ignorant of the subject under discussion. As we’ve just shown….

SUPPORT US WITH A SUBSCRIPTION?

3 COMMENTS

  1. Way off topic (or is it?) I’ve just been doing some research on invasive species for the village magazine. One of the problem species in the UK is the ‘Signal Crayfish’, a US species that’s out-competing our native (white-clawed) crayfish and (not unlike the imported grey squirrel) also carries a plague that kills them. But how does a purely freshwater crustacean get 3,000 miles across the Atlantic? Did some eggs arrive on water plants for aquariums? No (back on topic) it was a government scheme from the 70s – they deliberately imported signal crayfish to ‘farm’ for the ‘lucrative’ Scandinavian market. Who could ever have foreseen that they might escape? Nobody in government, that’s for sure.

  2. Lynas was financed by some Japs to build a rare earths refinery in Malaysia. A campaign against the thorium waste blew up – I noticed that the whingers in a Malaysian newspaper article were Chinese. Of course the Chinese don’t give a stuff about thorium from their own rare earth production. But then the campaign against low levels of radiation was always pushed by the Commies and their left wing mates from just after WW2.

    Anyway, Lynas made an arrangement with the West Australian government to pre-process their rare earth ores before sending them to Malaysia. Basically this means you extract the thorium here in Oz. Damned if I know when the place where they’ll dump it’ll fill up but at present there’s no problem.

    The US DOD has evidently made a deal with Lynas to export similar pre-refined ores to the US. So I’d say this one’s been solved. Not, I’ll admit Tim, that there was ever any real problem in the first place. (australianmining.com.au/news/lynas-to-feed-new-us-plant-with-kalgoorlie-rare-earths/) dated 22 Jan 21.

  3. The argument against an industrial policy works for most government policies.

    I had no idea who Alan Mak was, but wikipedia tells me he is Britain’s first Cantonese-heritage MP and a Tory to boot. Don’t rase a cheer. Apparently he lied about attending his local church in his 2015 election campaign, in which he also claimed to support Brexit. Once in the commons he campaigned for Remain and was a backbench toady for May. And he’s another lawyer.

    He is a fantastic example of why ‘diversity’ is such abject bollocks. A man born in Leeds to parents from Guangdong and he is no different from any other slimy Tory chancer. You couldn’t get a fag paper between him and an Etonian PPE graduate from Surrey.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

expunct

in British English
expunct (ɪkˈspʌŋkt)
VERB (transitive)
1. to delete or erase; blot out; obliterate
2. to wipe out or destroy

Support Us

Recent posts

To Introduce Environmentalists To Political Reality

Grist is part of that unthinking - the fat and thick end - of environmentalism. Which is why they ask questions like this: Why won’t...

Sperm Counts May Well Be Falling, Yes

A new reason we should all do something - or stop doing some other thing - which is that sperm counts are falling. If...

So, Revera Dodges Taxes, Does It?

Another one of the tax justice groupuscules wishes to tell us that Revera - a manager of care homes - dodges UK taxation. As we'd...

Free Speech Means The Liberty To Be A Pinhead

The Establishment - whichever one there is at any time - has been determined to beat back the threat of free speech ever since...

Just How Stupid Can You Be About British Recovery Bonds?

This Starmer idea of British Recovery Bonds. Or, as Richard Murphy is claiming, his idea of stealing everyones' savings. It's possible to wonder at...

Recent comments