Home Economics Strange And Weird Ways To Reform Unemployment Insurance

Strange And Weird Ways To Reform Unemployment Insurance



This might not be quite the way to do it in fact:

Under Wyden and Bennet’s scheme, states would be required to offer at least 26 weeks of regular UI benefits (some now provide as few as 14) and to replace 75 percent of workers’ wages (before Covid-19, the average was closer to 50 percent). If they don’t, employers in the state will get dinged on their federal unemployment taxes.

Gig and self-employed workers, those entering the labor force for the first time, and others who don’t qualify for traditional UI would get a “Jobseeker Allowance” of $250 a week for up to half a year. The plan would also resuscitate a mostly moribund provision of the UI system called “Extended Benefits,” which offers up to 13 additional weeks of benefits for the long-term unemployed and is meant to kick in during recessions but historically has been barely helpful. The plan would make the Extended Benefits program more generous, finance it in full using federal dollars, and have it automatically kick in when state or national unemployment goes above 5.5 percent.

Dinging employers with the unemployment taxes looks pretty strange. Because employers pay the state unemployment taxes. Which, if the unemployment benefits are going to be more generous will have to go up. So, the employers get screwed – sorry, presented with the bill – either way anyway. So what’s the incentive here? Why would employers march on the state capitol in order to demand, err, that they have to pay the same amount of money either way?

There are other incentive problems here. So, “those entering the labor for the first time”. High school kids at graduation say. Go get a job or, here’s $250 a week free and clear until Christmas. The incentive effect here is to increase the teen unemployment rate. To 100% in fact. I mean, seriously, come on, who wouldn’t take that deal?

And then there’s the extended benefits thing. As I’ve just pointed out elsewhere we cannot trust the US unemployment numbers at present and won’t be able to until October at the earliest. Because those expanded and extended unemployment benefits mean that it’s worth not getting a job for perhaps 25% of the American labor force. So, our cure for rising unemployment is going to be to subsidise unemployment some more? Yeah, that’ll work.

The progressive argument is that of technocracy. Get all the bright people to run things for us. The problem – one of them perhaps – is that it ain’t the bright people who get elected.



  1. This will probably increase unemployment and be a drag on the economy. But it will expand the bureaucracy and increase the number of people getting handouts from the State. Sounds like a Win-Win for the Dems.

  2. The progressive argument is that of technocracy. Get all the bright people to run things for us.

    As I recall, Friedrich Hayek had a few thoughts about that as a theory, never mind the practice of it. I believe that making an introduction to Hayek’s ideas part of the compulsory school curriculum would do wonders for the country’s economic and political literacy. Well, it would if you could find someone who understands the ideas enough to teach them.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


in British English
expunct (ɪkˈspʌŋkt)
VERB (transitive)
1. to delete or erase; blot out; obliterate
2. to wipe out or destroy

Support Us

Recent posts

The Bit That Robert Lighthizer Doesn’t Get

It's right here in the opening sentence of his piece in the New York Times: The Senate recently passed a bill intended to bolster America’s...

Brexit Brings Us Cheap Wine

There's a long way to go on this but this is indeed a start: The U.K. government said it will scrap a piece of planned...

Some At The Post Office Should Be Facing Significant Jail Time

Whether it's just a few or the many still remains to be worked out but there are definitely those at the Post Office who...

Another Beautiful Theory Destroyed By A Mere Fact

Apparently, so we're told, crime is soaring in the United States. But that's OK, we know the reason why. We even know what to...

Idiots – US Life Expectancy Hasn’t Fallen In The Slightest

It's important - actually, vital in both meanings here - to know what is being measured and how in order to understand what the...

Recent comments