Home Economics I Know! Let's Make America Poorer!

I Know! Let’s Make America Poorer!



This doesn’t really sound like the greatest of ideas to be honest, that the country should be made poorer. But that is what is being suggested here:

The country, once a manufacturing powerhouse, is populated by corporations that have moved manufacturing overseas and lost their ability to produce domestically, leaving little behind except shell companies that employ relatively few people. The United States no longer produces even the essentials, from personal protective equipment to our smartphones and laptops.

The huge short-term profits of this trend, coupled with impressive decreases in the prices of certain consumer goods, soothed many Americans. But the country lost sight of the critical requirements of a vibrant economy — which is good jobs.

Err, no. Manufacturing output is up at peak levels. OK, maybe not exactly this year but certainly better than those apparently golden years of the 60s and 70s.

Nope, that ain’t stuff made abroad and imported by American corporations. That’s value added inside the US. And that understates it too – now the canteen is done by outside contractors that’s a service, not the manufacturing it was when done in house in a manufacturing plant. So too the CAD work, design and all the rest.

And, of course, jobs, good or otherwise are a cost. Think on it. If we could gain everything without having to labour for it we’d be better off or not?


If products are going to be successfully manufactured in the United States, there must be sustained purchases by the government at the federal, state, and local levels, certainly for medical supplies but also in other industries.

After all, taxpayer money should not be used to subsidize foreign production. Companies that are given federal aid for crises should be required to move a significant percentage of their sourcing and production back to the United States. Stopping predatory pricing by foreign manufacturers is also necessary to ensure stable demand.

And in order to do this we’re going to make everything not only made in the USA but also more expensive. Predatory pricing here meaning “Cheaper than our folks”. Which does, of course, make everyone who buys the stuff – or is forced to – poorer of course.

So, that’s the plan. Just because a real, grown up, economy makes stuff that can be dropped on feet therefore everyone should be made poorer. It is a grand plan, isn’t it? Can’t think why anyone hasn’t recommended it before.

Dan Breznitz is a co-director of the Innovation Policy Lab at the Munk School of the University of Toronto and the author of the forthcoming “Innovation in Real Places: Strategies for Prosperity in an Unforgiving World.” David Adler writes frequently about industrial policy, as well as liquidity and financial frictions.

Well, actually, people did think of it before. Economists then examined it and filed it in the drawer market “Damn Stupidity”. But then what’s idiocy when there’s a book to sell?



    • Thanks for highlighting this. Spend an unqualified trillion and get X amount of crisis-ending supplies. Or require local manufacture and spend two, three, five trillion for the same amount of supplies. The Americans call this pork.

  1. Also notes it’s a Canadian university prof (possibly an Israeli national?) conspiring to make the USA poorer.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


in British English
expunct (ɪkˈspʌŋkt)
VERB (transitive)
1. to delete or erase; blot out; obliterate
2. to wipe out or destroy

Support Us

Recent posts

So Bjorn Lomborg Is Proven Right Once Again

Back when Bjorn Lomborg brought out the Sceptical Environmentalist my word how people laughed. He pointed out that well, actually, solar power had been...

So, That Answers The Question About Arun Advani Then

Arun Advani was on that Wealth Tax Commission. You know, the one that ended up saying that it would be just fine to have...

An Entirely Absurd Insistence About Oil Company Pay

The claim is that as oil company CEOs are paid with stock therefore they conspire to boil the planet. That is, no really, what...

Big Meat Is The Next Enemy After Big Oil

We would, perhaps, hope for a little more logical ability among those who write the newspapers and news sites for us. Take this example...

In Praise Of Benign, Even Helpful, Beneficial, Tax Competition

Richard Murphy tells us that it is not possible for there to be anything other than harmful tax competition. All such competition must, by...

Recent comments