Home Covid-19 Nesrine Malik's Cute But Useless Covid Cure

Nesrine Malik’s Cute But Useless Covid Cure



Nesrine Malik points out to us that those poor folk out there in poor countries are dying in their droves from the Covid virus. This is true. We should do something about this, that’s also true. What, exactly, we should do about this is rather more difficult.

The standard solution, that we need to get the poor countries to be rich is also true. But that’s a rather longer term project than might be reasonable right now. After all, an economy can only grow at perhaps 10% per year – sustainably that is, year after year. And it does take a few decades of that to get somewhere from the historical peasant destitution up to the sort of level where kife isw a more reasonable experience.

Take, say, DR Congo. Current estimates of GDP per capita are perhaps $600 a year. They can’t be far below that as that’s about the level at which a population is able to reproduce itself. The population isn’t falling – therefore GDP per capita can’t be far below that. OK, but 10% pa growth, about the fastest anywhere has ever managed over time would still take 30 years to get to global average of about $8,000. This is possible, China just did it, but this is still perhaps a rather longer term solution than we’re looking for.

So, what else?

But we shouldn’t have to wait for images like those to spur action. What is required is something far more ambitious than vaccine donations. The world needs a global logistical exercise, a sort of Marshall plan that would provide financial support, expert manpower and medical technology. In the US, Democratic senators, progressives, NGOs and an alliance of 175 former world leaders and Nobel laureates have come together to apply pressure on Biden to waive intellectual-property protections on vaccines. As the virus recedes in the west, now is the time to apply this kind of pressure on leaders to deliver the south from its almost certain fate. By the time the real numbers of deaths and infections in poorer countries become clear, it will be far too late for many people.

It’s all very trendy to demand that vacation of patents at present. But it wouldn’t do any good.

Every factory in the world that is capable of making vaccines already is. Any factory that wishes to make vaccines can gain access to those patents to do so. Vacating the patents wouldn’t make any difference to the number of factories nor their access to the patents. So, killing the patents wouldn’t make any difference to the number of dead patients at present. Further, any country can just declare an emergency and use any patent concerning drugs they like. Because, you know, emergency.

However, that vacation would produce harm in the immediate and further future. Because if the folks who have paid for this cure for a disease – and whatever one might say about government support there has been private money in here too – find out there’s no cash in having done so then they’ll not cough up, nor will anyone else, for the decades long process of finding cures for other diseases. Incentives, after all, do matter.

But then as we should all know these cries for killing patents on vaccines are nothing at all to do with Covid. It’s really part of a desire to kill patents and covid is the excuse.



  1. It seems to me that the most serious failing of lefties is their inability to see rather obvious unintended consequences.

  2. Lefties do not subscribe to Chesterton’s Fence admonition. It’s why they frequently appear to be stupid. No second level thinking.

  3. We did adopt a sort of global Marshall plan, with financial support, expert manpower and medical technology in the 19th century. People like Nesrine Malik hate it.

    Indeed if we were to readopt it, the first thing we’d need to do is send all the people like Nesrine Malik to the gas chamber. The second, of course, is dump this idiotic policy of winning their hearts and minds, and go back to killing the lot. After all, if God had meant us to leave anyone alive, He wouldn’t have invented the nuke.

    I must admit I prefer to leave the locals alone to go to hell after their own fashion rather than attempt to revive the empire. But I’ll admit I’m both lazy and stingy.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


in British English
expunct (ɪkˈspʌŋkt)
VERB (transitive)
1. to delete or erase; blot out; obliterate
2. to wipe out or destroy

Support Us

Recent posts

Getting The Rise Of The Billionaires Wrong

Much ink is spilled these days on the iniquitous rise of the number of billionaires. Some of this is just silly, With 2% inflation...

The Iniquity Of Utilities Asking People To Pay For Their Power

The Guardian gives us one of those lovely, deliberate, misrepresentations of an economic situation. The way this story is written the evil capitalists are...

They Never Will Make The Connection, No

American Prospect is the usual sorta left wing, progressive, type place. Government, especially the Federal government, should be put in charge of much more...

Green New Deal – These People Are Ignorant

The Green New Deal group has decided to favour us with their recommendations for how to make the UK a better place. Given who...

These People Are Mad – Rare Earths And Electronics Recycling

We're being told that we must waste resources in order to save resources. This is, of course, mad but then that's the institutional part...

Recent comments