Home Climate Change Green New Deal - These People Are Ignorant

Green New Deal – These People Are Ignorant



The Green New Deal group has decided to favour us with their recommendations for how to make the UK a better place. Given who actually wrote the report – Richard Murphy and Colin Hines – it’s as bad as you’d think it is.

Take this about the startling opportunities for the British steel industry:

Salvation of the UK Steel Industry?
Around one million heat pumps being fitted into homes every year for decades to come
should be a huge growth opportunity for the UK steel industry. Many of these homes
will also want domestic charging points for their electric vehicles. To meet the UK’s
commitment to phase out new petrol and diesel cars and vans by 2030 will also require
35,000 public electric vehicle charge points to be installed each year until then.
Put together, these two programmes are not only a source of long-term, skilled jobs in
every community, but they should also help save the UK steel industry where the
manufacture of heat pumps and chargers should be seen as a priority.
To help propel this shift, the government should make bailouts for, say, the
manufacturingxxviii and steel industriesxxix conditional on considering serious plans to secure
this decades-long domestic market.

A heat pump weighs 70 to 150 kg, that sort of amount. So, a million a year of them is 100,000 tonnes. They’re not all steel of course, there’s copper, aluminium etc in there too. But call it 100k tonnes. You know, roughly, between friends.

UK steel output is 8 million tonnes a year.

1.25% of current output is going to save British steel? They’re just not thinking about the scale of anything, are they?

They then make all the usual mistakes. Let’s create lots of Green jobs! But jobs are a cost, not a benefit. They think people should be saving for their pensions in 1% bonds. No, not paying themselves their pensions from a bond portfolio, that’s not too silly. But saving, now, for their future pension in 1% bonds. Insane.

They’ve also done their usual trick of not noting how the financing works. Money is raised in green bonds. Money is spent on green things. OK, cool, great. But then the who pays the interest and capital back all becomes very, umm, well, what? How do the houses who get the heat pumps pay back the money used to install the heat pumps? Everyone just gets a free heat pump from the government?

They’ve just not thought it through at all. But then, you know, Hines and Murphy.



  1. “They’re just not thinking about the scale of anything, are they?”

    This. Always this. Any time anyone says anything about renewals, they clearly have no sense of scale about what it would look like if that was our only source of energy.

    And don’t get me started on the energy wasted leaving things on standby…


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


in British English
expunct (ɪkˈspʌŋkt)
VERB (transitive)
1. to delete or erase; blot out; obliterate
2. to wipe out or destroy

Support Us

Recent posts

Expunct comes of age (sorta)

Today is the proper one year anniversary of the launch of expunct. It's been a rollercoaster but we wanted to create a site to...

We Can Help Salon Out Here Over Abortion And The Biden Administration

It's entirely true that abortion is one of those difficult questions. It's even true that the answers rather divide Americans. However, it's still possible...

Nick Dearden Really Is A Ghastly Oik

Dearden is from Global Justice Now - the usual bunch of Trots who never quite have left mother's basement. Their political views haven't advanced...

So Here’s The Actual Complaint About Amazon’s Diversity

It's possible that Amazon is simply packed full of thuggish racists who delight in keeping the poor folk down. Possible, even if perhaps a...

Government Health Care Causes Corruption

This isn't what Transparency International quite means to say here but it is indeed what they are saying. Government provided health care leads to...

Recent comments