Home Business The Judiciary Committee's Finding On Tech Company Monopolies

The Judiciary Committee’s Finding On Tech Company Monopolies



There are many things that can be said about the Judicial Committee’s investigation into the tech companies and possible monopolies. Or, to use a slightly weaker formulation, market power. One that did immediately strike is that in the intro we’re told that it was a bipartisan investigation. Which is true, but this report is not bipartisan, it’s purely and only the Ds on the committee shouting about what they think. It is, that is, something of a biased reading of that evidence collectively collected.

Which does pose something of a problem. For there’s a split – largely coincident with political lines although not exactly so – over views on monopoly and market power. On the one side those who insist that any market player with market power is something that needs to be controlled, that power curtailed. This is largely a D belief and is similarly coincident with the insistence that politics only must be allowed to have such power. As if having Sherrod Brown BigIAmming over us is better than having Jeff Bezos doing so.

Well, OK, we can see the attraction for this set up among those who might become Senator Brown but without the skill, talent or application to become Jeff Bezos. The rest of us may or may not agree.

On the other side there’s the argument that sure, significant market power isn’t all that desirable, but there’s a limit to how much intervention we want to do into the economy. This is largely an R belief, or perhaps a free market one an that’s coincident with those few Rs who actually believe in free markets. So, there should be intervention into market power, monopoly, only when there’s actual – and provably so – harm to consumers. The cartel forcing up vitamin prices, as happened in the EU, kill it with fire and fine everybody billions. As was done. Someone with the bulk of a market simply because they’re very good at it for the moment, well, leave it alone.

Any discussion of market power, of monopoly, has to start with this divergence in theoretical views about it. At which point we can dismiss this report. Rather easily. For in the intro:

The effects of this significant and durable market power are costly. The Subcommittee’s series of hearings produced significant evidence that these firms wield their dominance in ways that erode entrepreneurship, degrade Americans’ privacy online, and undermine the vibrancy of the free and
diverse press. The result is less innovation, fewer choices for consumers, and a weakened democracy.

They’re not even claiming consumer harm and they’re certainly not proving its existence. That is, consumer harm as in people being charged more than a market clearing price for what they’re getting. They’ve begged the major and important question that is – so we can and should ignore them.



  1. Since I know absolutely nothing about business, I can only use my usual selfishness to ask how it affects me. At present it’s not causing me any problems, so I’d say leave well enough alone.

    I certainly do not agree with any regulation unless it’s really necessary. As a former bureaucrat, I whole-heartedly agree with Adam Smith’s opinion that the best thing a bureaucrat can do is nothing. Fortunately most bureaucrats don’t find this difficult.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here


in British English
expunct (ɪkˈspʌŋkt)
VERB (transitive)
1. to delete or erase; blot out; obliterate
2. to wipe out or destroy

Support Us

Recent posts

Venning’s Law Of Questions

"The correct answer to any question which contains the word "surely" is no." John Venning, formerly of Downside, latterly St. Paul's.

Spot The Error From Aditya Chakrabortty

So, Aditya wants us all to know that poverty is a big and serious problem in Britain. I certainly think it would be somewhere...

That Idea That Slavery Built America Is A Bit Too Marxist To Be True

In among those arguments in favour of reparations for slavery is the idea that slavery is what actually built America therefore large amounts should...

Biden’s $15 Minimum Wage Is Going To Be A Disaster

The effects of this rise in the Federal minimum wage to $15 are going to be slow in arriving, this is true. That's what...

Seriously Folks, Tech Company Taxation Is A Problem That’s Solved Already

It would be interesting if the pages of our national newspapers were less than four years out of date. Well, obviously, they're allowed to...

Recent comments